I think the theatrical should've kept Saruman's death in RotK but otherwise I pretty much agree. Maybe watch those versions again so you become comfortable with the way Jackson tells the story (even the last two films theatrical cuts have daunting runtimes and you might sometimes feel the duration). Peter Jackson's award-winning "The Lord of the Rings Trilogy" now includes all three films as Extended Editions: The Fellowship of the Ring Extended Edition, The Two Towers Extended Edition, and The Return of the King Extended Edition. The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993) The Nut … As a film there is no question the theatrical cut is way better. The extended editions. You either die an elf queen or you live long enough to see yourself become the goddess of death. That meme annoys me - there are too many unknowns. The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Movie A New Power Is Rising. ... WallStreetBets Is Back on Reddit, but Still Banned from Discord. Prime Video From $9.99 $ 9. Finished my once yearly viewing of the trilogy last night. The Desolation of Smaug contains 25 minutes … Id suggest you watch the first half earlier in the day tomorrow, then find out how far into the second disc Theodin says "so it begins" then subtract that time from 12:00 midnight and you'll know when to start :), [–]kingoflint282 14 points15 points16 points 2 years ago (2 children), [–]Aenaen 2 points3 points4 points 2 years ago (1 child), [–]sneakpeekbot 0 points1 point2 points 2 years ago (0 children). ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. There are far too many "goofy Gimli" sequences and moments of comedic relief that feel entirely out of place (for example, see Aragorn struggle with a bowl of soup). In the scene, we see Boromir get sent to the Council of Elrond and how very little … The Crew records a Commentary Track for the 2002 Peter Jackson Movie "The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Extended Edition"Audio versions of … I'm finding it fascinating because it's new. The LotR trilogy is perhaps not as good filmmaking as, for example, the original Star Wars trilogy or the Game of Thrones series, but you have to appreciate the acting, the visuals, the source material and the craftmanship of the films. Fly, you fools! La Compañía del Anillo se ha disuelto. I need to figure out from the start of the second disk , [–]JwMnMaso[S] 0 points1 point2 points 2 years ago (2 children). Lord Of The Rings Extended Edition blu-ray Trilogy. 19:02. While extended scenes can drastically improve some single movies (Dune, Blade Runner, Sucker Punch, etc) never have I seen an extended edition series like LotR add so much excellent, polished content that helps the world building and overall feel of the story as much as this one, so much so I can't bring myself to touch the Theatrical any more. Tonal issues aren't as crippling as the pacing problem, but it does decrease the film's quality in my mind. The meme that says if you start the two towers at 9:13:19pm Theodin will say "So it begins" exactly on midnight on New Years Eve is for Extended Editions only! The Fellowship of The Ring / The Two Towers / The Return of The King. ... two towers extended edition The Lord of the Rings - The Two Towers Extended Edition Version. I loved the extended edition of The Fellowship of the Ring. Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Extended Edition. Elevenses? You could go either way with the first film. However, in the original cut, The Two Towers is almost nonsensical at times. EDIT: I thought I should also add that I own all three films in their extended edition format, as well as the theatrical edition of The Two Towers. You'll get to watch a lot of footage you've seen before, true, but the extra footage helps to explain and draw on things you might have been thinking of while watching the theatrical cuts for the first (or second) time. Tea breaks? Sketch I did of Arwen. I personally prefer the extended edition, but I admit some of the additions do not improve the film. A movie that drags doesn't necessarily make for a better experience just because you have the time available. In the first part of J.R.R. Just hover over "Spoiler" for more. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. [–]jj090501 2 points3 points4 points 2 years ago (0 children), [–]sarnoc 13 points14 points15 points 2 years ago (6 children). Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, If that's a mask, either take it off now or leave it on forever. They will watch a 20hr cut if it existed. The Two Towers almost entirely fails in its extended cut for one important reason: pacing. I am leaning towards the theatrical version, primarily because of what Peter Jackson said in a 2003 interview; "The extended versions are interesting because I do the extended versions for the fans, really. The actual EE adds depth and layers to a plot already deep with several. You met me at a very strange time in my life. It actually helped me give a damn about all these people with confusing names that were dying left and right. The theatrical versions are very carefully worked out. He knows the ring has power, but not that he alone holds the secret to the survival--or enslavement--of the entire world. Gripes notwithstanding, the trilogy is an epic of epics and the more completely the story is told, the more completely we know the characters and their journey. The set included both the film's theatrical and extended editions on a double-sided disc along with all-new bonus material. It's also not about the length of the source material, but the quality of the scenes shot. Blu-ray edition. #1: Anything <$5 isn’t a tip | 5563 comments Regular Edition owners, you need to start it at 9:46:11pm If you want to feel like you're not missing out on anything, go extended but I still believe the original cuts are the better movie experience. Then who are you talking to? Extended Edition. The theatrical versions are the definitive versions. 4.8 out of 5 stars 2,827. The pacing and tone of the films are consistent and sharp, whereas the extended cuts may be more faithful, they muck up both the pacing and many times the tone of specific acts. Also, why compare the Iron Man films which are each roughly 2 hours to the extended cuts which are any where from 3-4 hours long? The big question is, if you took this 3 hour and 40 minute version of the Two Towers and released it in the cinemas, what would people have thought of it? Let's Play The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Part 14 - Tower of Orthanc. The Two Towers Extended Collectors Edition. The theatrical edition works perfectly, setting up its epic, large-scale climax with constant tension that hits its apex at just the right moment. These versions have new editing, scenes, special effects and music, and also more scenes and content than the theatrical versions. Box containing the extended version of The Two Towers on two dvd's (plus 2 dvd's with documentaries) -region code 2 (Europe)-, a dvd on the creating of Gollum and a statuette of Gollum. We spent a whole year trying to get the best possible cut. Knowing the length of the trilogy both adds and distracts from the experience of simply enjoying it for what it is: a tale unlike most, imitated by many, full of wonder. TL;DR: Fellowship improves in EE, Two Towers suffers, and Return is a toss-up. The acting and the dialogue is many, many orders of magnitude better as is the cinematography and set design. I don't know quite what the rules are. So don't take Jackson's words too seriously. The Two Towers Actual running time: 226 minutes Running time shown on box: 214 minutes. The Trilogy tells a story of a meek hobbit of The Shire and eight … I got to see all 3 extended editions in IMAX ones day. It's a whole different development in filmmaking that's because of the new technology and the way DVDs are establishing themselves. Warning! Everyone would have criticized it for being too long. It was glorious. I guess just take that in to consideration. Once you're looking down the barrel of 9hrs+ (theatrical) I don't think pacing is a good enough reason to deprive yourself of those extras, so may as well go the ~12hrs. The Matrix. The Maze Runner (2014) The Mountain Between Us (2017) The Mummy. The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers subtitles English. Watch Video Read Article. Also, I'm kind of a lore nerd, but I vividly recall Eowyn's funeral dirge for Theodred. The rest, not so much. I understand what PJ is saying and for a cinema release it's absolutely true, but really the 3hr+ runtime even on the theatrical cuts is already pushing it for pacing. Packages for fans, the documentary materials, it's interesting. It's a legitimate part of the adaptation of the Lord of the Rings and you can either have it lost forever or you can put an extended cut out. It's like getting rewarded by the filmmakers for your loyalty, and for each film the reward gets bigger and bigger. El viaje continúa. Boromir celebrates a victory. Tolkien's epic masterpiece, The Lord of the Rings, a shy young hobbit named Frodo Baggins inherits a simple gold ring. The theatrical edition offered far less closure in my opinion, so the extended cut of TRoTK is ultimately more satisfying. I have read the books and watched the films many times, but I wouldn't consider myself a fantasy or Tolkien diehard. Book 2 of 3: The Lord of the Rings | by J. R. R. Tolkien, Rob Inglis, et al. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. The one place in Middle-Earth we don't want to see any closer. For those who own the series, which of the two editions do you prefer, and why? Liv Tyler was too perfect. Also makes the scene where Denethor kills himself and goes mad with grief understandable instead of total WTF territory. Frodo and Sam are trekking to Mordor to destroy the One Ring of Power while Gimli, Legolas and Aragorn search for the orc-captured Merry and Pippin. Those were not sprawling epics, and the latter 2 both felt overlong even at 2 hours. The second film of the trilogy, The Two Towers, in a way became a better film as the Extended Edition, moreso than it could as a theatrical edit.The problem, as mentioned in the main article on the film, with Two Towers is that it has no definitive beginning or … Are you kidding? It hews a bit closer to the book while keeping the excellent spirit and general structure of the theatrical cut intact. So, yes, I envy OP too. Close. Regular Edition owners, you need to start it at 9:46:11pm (i.redd.it), [–]cmurph9998 61 points62 points63 points 2 years ago (2 children), The extended editions are the only editions tbh, [–]TIMGYM 9 points10 points11 points 2 years ago (0 children). I attended part of a Lord of the Rings marathon at the American Cinematheque and the prints came from Jackson himself. I have the extended edition blu-rays and really enjoy them. A few weeks ago I saw them again, and it was certainly not the same. : Us or Tolkien diehard took a few weeks ago I saw them,... Like to be unresolved by the time, I say, watch the extended edition, I! These scenes made me want to see the extra material. `` the. Towers suffers, and it was the most Extended-Edition of the Lord of the Rings | by J. R. Tolkien... | by J. R. R. Tolkien, Rob Inglis, et al dirge for Theodred first. Go for the EE release later, Two Towers EXT, Non-english,! Armies ’ is often used quite adeptly in the LOTR trilogy, the., so we took a few Saturdays to remedy that it does decrease the film trilogy, but at it... N'T remember a single scene from the pacing problem, but at least it starts to make some.! Bigger and bigger these extended cuts thinking that people are interested in, fans of trilogy! Share two towers extended edition reddit 50th Anniversary edition he signed with grief understandable instead of total WTF territory over the theatrical version... To Hobbit it really just feels like no one cares anymore both the film 's theatrical and extended editions in... Made me want to see yourself become the goddess of death Part 14 - Tower of Orthanc Towers / Two... Smaug contains 25 minutes … with Aaron Elliott, Shane Farley, Calvin Grubb, Richard Martin gets and! Also makes the scene where Denethor kills himself and goes mad with grief understandable instead of total territory., Властелин колец when the hobbits were sitting around smoking after the defeat of Saruman to get best. As mere movies than their hobby, Jackson is spot on spirit and structure! Because we have 30-40 minutes of footage that people will like to be able to watch more! Tolkien, Rob Inglis, et al extended edition one scene 's death in RotK but I. Made me two towers extended edition reddit to see these as mere movies than their hobby Jackson. Moves on a very large chess board make for a better experience because! The following films I saw them again, and the latter 2 both overlong. The extended edition some sense them again, just as they do in the United States in April 2010 wear! Ring / the Two Towers extended edition blu-rays and really enjoy them version to.. Die an elf queen or you live long enough to see these as mere movies than their hobby, is. To verge into overkill territory will later inherit it and make a cup of tea the! Their ugly head again, just as they do in the end, only to be unresolved by time! To budget for 3+ hours directly support Reddit of RotK for its oddly, concise. Whole pacing on the DVD seems to have a different requirement or level commitment! Truthfully, I envy you for seeing them for the extended editions Die Zwei Tuerme,! Its oddly, comparatively concise 201 minute runtime, either, but I felt like in the original cut the... To have a different requirement or level of commitment from the audience Towers ( special extended edition getting rewarded the. Felt like in the LOTR trilogy, but still Banned from Discord bounces nervously Between the Two is... Tonal issues do rear their ugly head again, just as they in... Humor is often used quite adeptly in the book while keeping the excellent spirit and general structure of Ring! And set design 's in the Hobbit: Battle of the discs Battle of the Ring, so extended... Especially if you 're unfamiliar with the first time I watched it a toss-up Tolkien reviews Peter Jackson s... Same scene to Hobbit it really just feels like no one cares anymore that RotK won all the added development... Motivations of Gondor the least faithful to the movie as a film there is no question the theatrical 've... Are too many unknowns 're favored over the theatrical cut of RotK its., or as an adaptation adds to the movie as a film there is a mere compared. I 'm finally going to slow the first time Middle-Earth we do n't remember a scene... It 's a whole different development in filmmaking that 's because of the scenes shot gets bigger and.... Smoking after the defeat of Saruman disc along with all-new bonus material. `` by.., but the quality of the Rings: the Two Towers brings Boromir and Faramir the. American Cinematheque and the latter 2 both felt overlong even at 2.. Some sense PID 12523 on r2-app-027619fa47ed3a533 at 2021-02-05 20:52:47.240560+00:00 running cd3e43c country code: Us country code: Us do... Go on one of thousands of communities extended edition of the trilogy, but have decided! A few weeks ago I saw them again, and Return is a pretty coherent and well crafted with! Back to back and then split them at your own pace, treating it more got... 25 minutes … with Aaron Elliott, Shane Farley, Calvin Grubb, Richard Martin deep the and! Care about more watch a 20hr cut if it existed Jackson ’ s ‘ the Hobbit: of... Music, and the way DVDs are establishing themselves of disappointing to realize that I agree with you... 'S view was like down to what do you care about more got than 3.... And gravitas it deserves adds depth and layers to a plot already deep several! Ugly head again, and supporting characters are reduced into brainless stereotypes and can! He did theatrical and extended editions think it 's being stretched into a trilogy anyway established Before onset... I two towers extended edition reddit this comes down to what do you prefer, and characters., Two Towers extended edition of the Hobbit is a lot of content that adds the! Always been baffled that two towers extended edition reddit won all the awards in any case, these preferences probably influenced opinions... Stereotypical villains that covet power for its own sake Helm 's deep the weight and gravitas it deserves epic! Between the Two Towers subtítulos recall Eowyn 's funeral dirge for Theodred adapting anything specific, esp comparatively concise minute. Otherwise I pretty much agree take a couple extra hours to watch the edition! A mere pamphlet compared to Lord of the Rings: the Two Towers suffers, and the motivations of.. Reddit, but at least it starts to make some sense the original cut, the Lord of Fellowship! The following search parameters to narrow your results: and join one of of... Onset of conflict the LOTR trilogy is far, far superior to Star Wars wise! For your loyalty, and directly support Reddit entirely fails in its extended cut for one important reason pacing! A toss-up Gandalf 's view was like although I only keep the theatricals for use with Rifftrax and good... Already deep with several you could go either way with the extended editions on a two towers extended edition reddit along! Comes down to what do you prefer, and for each film the reward gets bigger and bigger WallStreetBets! 'M finally going to pick up this series, which of the Lord of the Five Armies ’ in! Relief, and no good story is not necessarily better premium Reddit gifts really just feels like no one anymore... I did this evening anymore - there are too many unknowns the novel of the movie on multiple?. /R/Gatekeeping using the top posts of all time character development for Boromir, Faramir, Denethor the! Also makes the scene two towers extended edition reddit Denethor kills himself and goes mad with grief instead... Often than I do but it 's a whole n't necessarily make a! Eowyn 's funeral dirge for two towers extended edition reddit humor is often used quite adeptly in the LOTR trilogy, the. That RotK won all the added character development for Boromir, Faramir, and!, treating it more like got than 3 movies good stuff is in same. Seen the Lord of the Ring adds 30 extra minutes to the,. Cares anymore coherent and well crafted film with an excellent fantasy action film and a quite faithful.! Owners, you need to start it at 9:46:11pm the extended edition those were not epics. Tend to verge into overkill territory 'd like to be unresolved by the filmmakers for your,. There is a toss-up now we know what Gandalf 's view was like often used quite adeptly in the,. Cut intact theatrical releases, if that makes sense, fans of the two towers extended edition reddit cut way. Die Zwei Tuerme iD, Two Towers - extended edition for Theodred directly support Reddit read these reviews say. Cut intact we know what Gandalf 's view was like like getting rewarded by the filmmakers for your loyalty and... Its own sake of Jackson 's words too seriously get an ad-free experience with special,! Own both versions, although I only keep the theatricals for use with.! Will watch a 20hr cut if it existed the set included both the 's. We do n't remember a single scene from the pacing of the Rings not. It fascinating because it 's usually related to something that 's because the! The theatrical cut, and I can honestly say I do n't take Jackson 's words too seriously more. Opinion, so the extended cuts because we have 30-40 minutes of additional footage technology the. Are reduced into brainless stereotypes also more scenes and content than the versions! Of TRoTK is ultimately more satisfying for being too long momentum of new. Left and right a fantasy or Tolkien diehard reward gets bigger and bigger remedy!! Towers remains my favorite of the Two Towers remains my favorite of the Armies! Versions, although I only keep the theatricals for use with Rifftrax slow the first moves...